Comparison of Japanese Self-Storage to the U.S. market
By Stephen Spohn
On a recent visit to a self-storage conference and tradeshow in Las Vegas, it was clear most participants knew little about Japan’s self-storage industry. That wasn’t necessarily a surprise. A total of zero U.S. storage operators are doing business in Japan. However, I was surprised at the degree of curiosity and interest whenever I was able to engage in conversation about the Japanese industry. I also found it interesting that many U.S. operators are wrestling with some of the same issues facing Japanese operators:
- The general lack of awareness among consumers about the different grades of product
- The general lack of reliable industry statistics
- Rental-rate management and optimization
- The effectiveness of various advertising vehicles, including the increasing use of online media
- Leveraging technology to increase efficiency and, ultimately, profitability
Perhaps the markets are more similar than any of us realize. The following is an overview of self-storage in Japan and a comparison of the U.S. and Japanese markets.
Market Size, Penetration and Growth
In comparison to other self-storage markets in the world, Japan’s is significant as measured by revenue but relatively young and undeveloped as measured by saturation (see the accompanying table).
||Revenue in $USD
|Sources：Selfstorage.org, Selfstorage.com.au, FEDESSA.org, Japan Selfstorage Association, CSSA.ca, SSAUK.com
For the last decade, storage supply has been growing, and it continues to grow by roughly 10 percent per year, based on the 2010 Japanese self-storage supply survey conducted by operator Quraz as well as information published by other large self-storage players. Growth has generally been fueled by an improvement in the quality of storage facilities and an increased awareness of that better quality. Between the third quarter of 2008 and the third quarter of 2010, unit supply grew 19 percent. The top five competitors, identified accompany chart, represent 60 percent of the market.
||Gross Potential Revenue($USD)
|Arealink(dba Hello Storage)
|＊Aggregote list price of units, assuming 90 percent occupancy
|Sources：2010 Japanese self-storage supply survey conducted by Quraz, as well as infomation published by other large self-storage players
In terms of industry lifecycle, it might be useful to compare the stage of the Japanese storage market in 2011 to that of the U.S. storage market in 1970. Specifically, saturation was less than 0.5 percent in the United States, maybe only slightly more than Japan at present day (0.2 percent). It remains to be seen if saturation in Japan will approach U.S. levels, although growth rates are similar to those of the United States 40 years ago.
The fundamental nature of the storage product and its use is, not surprisingly, quite similar between Japan and the United States, that being space, rentable on a month-to-month basis, to store personal property outside of the home or office. However, there are several product and business-model differences that are important in understanding the Japanese market.
Unit Sizes and Rates
The average storage-unit sizes in Japan and the United States are roughly 30 square feet and 150 square feet, respectively. In Japan, a very popular unit size is one to two tatami (a type of mat used as a flooring material in traditional Japanese-style rooms, measuring approximately 18 square feet) as compared to a 10-by-15 unit (150 square feet) in the United States.
There are three primary reasons for the difference in size. First, Americans are much heavier consumers than Japanese. They simply buy and have more and bigger “stuff.” Second, the average living area per household in Japan is just 1,020 square feet, based on information from the 2003 Housing and Land Survey by the Japan Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications. In Tokyo, homes are much smaller, often only 300 to 500 square feet. Given the limited living space, consumers will often use a 20-square-foot self-storage space as an extra closet or extension of their homes.
Finally, storage-rental rates are simply much higher in Japan, due in part to the fact that real estate in general is more expensive, compounded by the fact that storage facilities tend to be located in more densely populated urban areas in Japan. Monthly rental rates in Japan average approximately $6 per square foot, which is four to six times average U.S. rates. It’s simply more difficult for consumers to afford a 100-square-foot storage unit in Japan. Simply put, Japanese consumers choose smaller storage units for the same reasons they choose smaller living areas.
The top three Japanese self-storage operators, comprising nearly 50 percent of the market, each pursue different business models. Quraz generally pursues a conversion model whereby it purchases under utilized or misplaced office properties and converts them to self-storage facilities. This is the most similar to models in other parts of the world, including the United States, whereby the operator also owns the assets.
Arealink’s model is generally to lease single or multiple floors in under utilized office buildings, install storage units, and sublet the space to end users. This leasing model is the predominant storage business model in Japan, due in part to the relatively high price and low availability of real estate in urban areas.
Reise generally pursues a third model whereby landowners contract with the company to install a two-floor self-storage facility, with Reise managing the facility on behalf of the owner. This model might be similar to the third-party management services offered by some of the larger U.S. operators. Approximately 25 percent of storage capacity in Japan is owned by the operator, 50 percent is leased by the operator, and 25 percent is managed by the operator.
Indoor vs. Container Storage
Excluded from the above Japanese self-storage market statistics is outdoor, container storage, which operates using something similar to a marine or shipping container. Several operators, including Arealink and Kase, offer container storage to businesses and consumers who do not require the safety and security of an indoor facility.
Containers are placed on vacant, generally suburban land. The storage operator either rents the vacant land from the landowner and sublets the containers, or he manages the containers on behalf of the landowner who owns them.
As of the third quarter of 2010, there were approximately 2,700 container facilities and 92,000 storage containers in Japan, owned or managed by approximately 110 operators (some of which also operate indoor storage facilities). The gross potential revenue of these containers amounts to approximately $190 million, or 70 percent of the indoor storage market.
Over the past several years, the growth in container-storage capacity has appeared to slow significantly, likely due likely to two reasons: a wider awareness of the benefits of indoor self-storage, and the fact that containers have come under increasing scrutiny as often being noncompliant with various building codes. Additionally, there is generally a poor consumer perception about the safety and quality of container sites. Many indoor self-storage operators (myself included) believe container sites harm the perception of self-storage in Japan.
The self-storage industry in Japan is growing and is, in many ways, similar to the U.S. market. Perhaps Japanese operators will someday enjoy the same level of success enjoyed by their U.S. counterparts. They share many of the same challenges, and face an equally bright future.
Stephen Spohn is the president of Quraz, Japan’s largest owner and operator of self-storage facilities. Spohn has been living and working in Tokyo for nearly four years. He can be contacted at email@example.com.
(In alphabetical order)
- 2003 Housing and Land Survey, Japan Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications
- CSSA.ca [Canada Self Storage Association]
- FEDESSA.org [Federation of European Self Storage Associations]
- apan Self Storage Association
- Quraz 2010 Japanese Self-Storage Supply Survey
- SelfStorage.org [Self Storage Association, U.S. National]
- SelfStorage.com.au [Self Storage Association of Australasia]
- SSAUK.com [Self Storage Association of the United Kingdom]